Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

excluding certain categories (e.g. unprepared food…

And then there are court cases about whether this is a biscuit or a cake. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaffa_Cakes#Cake_or_biscuit.3F



There are always court cases about silly things; you don't need taxes for that. Five years ago, a Massachusetts judge ruled in a commercial leasing lawsuit that a burrito is not a sandwich: http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=...


No doubt it gets to be a little weird, but unprepared is a pretty well defined thing if you don't do what the federal food stamp program in the US does and type of food shouldn't really matter. If it requires cooking or is primarily an ingrediant then no tax.

US weird stuff: If you buy a frozen burrito it is ok. Unless the store has a microwave and you use it, then it is not ok. If you go home and microwave it then it is ok.


> unprepared is a pretty well defined thing

Okay - provide the definition and we'll see how well it works. Note that we're not as good at this sort of thing as tax lawyers.

If you go with/retreat to "we'll get experts to define it" ....


I don't have to define it, it is in the law books in several states - even the fed food stamp program has its own version which I mentioned is problematic.


Actually, you do, or at least provide a useable cite, because you claimed that there's a good definition but only mentioned bad ones.

Let's see a good/not-problematic definition.


Most of foods (fruits, chocolate, chips, milk, just anything) don't require cooking, and are not primarily ingredients.


milk and fruits are often considered ingredients in these laws - chocolate is too, chips are often taxed. stuff gets complicated depending on who wrote the law.

what's with the down votes - I didn't write the damn laws like this




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: