Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Every business that makes sense will try to make its customers happier.

Showing people bad news to get more engagement has roughly the same moral standing as the evening news.

I guess I don't get it.

[It must be wrong because they learned something from it, I guess?]



What's your position on creating fake news to get more engagement? Some lines are defended because the slippery slope on the other side is infinite.


I'm opposed to lying, I don't imagine that's controversial.

If the slope is so slippery smooth there has got to be a point in between changing the details of an arbitrarily complex sort and filter default on a social network site and purposely propagating lies.


Well, where is it when not where you are purposely changing those sort and filter defaults with the explicit goal of changing people's perception of the world in a way intentionally not in line with their interest?


The thing about the slippery slope is that it is far more often a logical fallacy than it is a real danger.


http://pando.com/2014/06/28/facebooks-science-experiment-on-...

"Facebook itself could target certain users, whether they be corporate rivals or current/former employees. Having such strong psychological control over your workforce would certainly have its benefits. And if Facebook ever gets caught? Why, the company could claim it’s all part of a social experiment, one that users tacitly agreed to when they signed up.

With over one-tenth of the world’s population signing into Facebook every day, and now with evidence to back the emotional power of the company’s algorithmic manipulation, the possibilities for widespread social engineering are staggering and unlike anything the world has seen. Granted, Facebook’s motives probably are simply to convince people to buy more stuff in order to please advertisers, but the potential uses of that power to impact elections or global trade could be enticing to all sorts of powerful interest groups."


The thing about fallacies is that you can't claim one just because it's common.

The thing about this case is that network effects of communication services make for very strong path dependence, thus making it extremely hard to get back up the slope a bit if you notice you've been slipping down a bit too much.


Well that's pretty much every news portal out there, for the definition of 'fake' as 'not matching reality'.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: